Associate Professor and Head
Department of Music
Sikkim University
Abstract:
This research proposal critically examines the portrayal of women in Indian music, with a particular focus on the song texts of Khayāl. Through a detailed analysis of lyrics, the study explores recurring themes, gender stereotypes, and the evolving roles of women as depicted in Khayāl compositions. By tracing the historical context and societal influences that have shaped these portrayals, the paper highlights how traditional and contemporary narratives reflect broader cultural attitudes toward women. Additionally, the contributions of female musicians and composers are investigated to understand their impact on the representation of women in this classical music tradition. The analysis also considers the effects of globalization and cross-cultural influences on these portrayals. The findings reveal a complex interplay between tradition and modernity, shedding light on the ongoing transformation of gender dynamics within Indian music. This study aims to contribute to the broader discourse on gender and cultural representation in Hindustani classical music.
Keyword: Keywords: Khyāl, Hindustani Classical Music, Women in Music, Gender Representation, Music and Identity.
Introduction
The representation of women in the domain of Indian classical music, particularly through the lens of Khayāl song lyrics, reveals a complex tapestry of depiction that reflects societal norms, cultural ideals, and the evolving dynamics of gender roles within this musical tradition. This critique seeks to unravel the nuanced portrayals of female characters, exploring both their moments of empowerment and instances of objectification within the lyrical narratives, alongside the broader implications these depictions hold for modern interpretations of women in Indian classical music (McVicker, 2011). By examining the historical context and thematic elements present in Khayāl compositions, one can gain a richer insight into how these representations have impacted and been impacted by the larger narrative concerning women’s roles within societal structures. (McClary, 1990). This exploration reveals the complexities of female representation in Khayāl, highlighting how these musical narratives both challenge and reinforce traditional gender norms while influencing modern interpretations of women’s identities in Indian culture (Viljoen, 2014).Through this lens, we can appreciate how Khayāl serves not only as a form of entertainment but also as a powerful vehicle for social commentary, allowing women to navigate and negotiate their identities within the constraints of cultural expectations. This dual role of Khayāl underscores its significance as a site for both artistic innovation and cultural critique, offering a platform where women’s voices can resonate and evolve in response to the changing societal landscape(Alaghband-Zadeh, 2015).By examining the intricate layers of Khayāl, we can uncover how these musical narratives reflect and shape the evolving discourse around women’s roles in society, ultimately contributing to a richer understanding of gender dynamics within Indian cultural practices. This exploration reveals not only the resilience of women’s expressions but also highlights how Khayāl serves as a mirror to societal transformations, challenging traditional norms and advocating for greater agency in the lives of women (Lam, 2018).Through this lens, Khayāl becomes more than just a musical form; it transforms into a powerful vehicle for social change, empowering women to articulate their experiences and assert their identities in a rapidly changing world (Koskoff, 1987). This analysis begins by situating khayāl not merely as a musical genre, but as a vital medium for the expression and negotiation of gender roles throughout Indian history. The intricate interplay between lyrics, melody, and performance offers insights into the socio-cultural dimensions of women’s identities, particularly as they navigate the traditionally male-dominated music scene. By drawing upon interdisciplinary frameworks, including gender studies and ethnomusicology, the analysis emphasizes how song texts embody both historical and contemporary perspectives on womens experiences. Such an approach echoes the findings of (Caranti et al.), which highlight the interconnectedness of musical forms and societal norms, while also engaging with the complexities noted in (Tabor et al.) regarding the nuanced sociocultural practices surrounding music gatherings. Furthermore, the image serves to contextualise these discussions, presenting a lens through which to observe the theoretical underpinnings of khayāl performance.
Background of Indian Classical Music
Indian classical music has deep roots in the country’s rich cultural heritage, evolving over centuries and reflecting a diverse array of traditions and philosophies. This intricate tapestry of sound and rhythm not only showcases the artistic expressions of various regions but also serves as a mirror to the societal values and transformations that have shaped Indian society throughout history(Bull, 2015).The evolution of Indian classical music has been influenced by various historical events, including the patronage of royal courts, colonial encounters, and contemporary globalisation, each contributing to its rich diversity and adaptability. As a result, Indian classical music continues to thrive today, blending traditional forms with modern influences while fostering a sense of identity and continuity among its practitioners and audiences (Paranjape, 2012). Khayāl, a vital genre within Indian classical music, embodies a unique confluence of musical improvisation and emotional expression, making it instrumental in portraying intricate human experiences, particularly those related to womanhood. This genre, distinguishing itself through its lyrical themes and melodic richness, allows for a nuanced exploration of womens roles and emotions within its song texts. As discussed in research that analyzes the interplay of historical context and thematic content in Khayāl, this genre serves as both a reflection of societal norms and a vehicle for personal expression, creating spaces for female voices, even in a patriarchal milieu (Caranti et al.). The relevance of Khayāl in contemporary discourse is further emphasized by its ability to transcend traditional structures, offering innovative interpretations of poetry, often echoing the bhakti and courtly influences that underpin its evolution (Tabor et al.). Such dynamics are beautifully illustrated in works like, showcasing the depth of emotive engagement within this musical form. This evolution in music not only reflects the dynamic nature of artistic expression but also highlights the importance of inclusivity and shared experiences in creating a more interconnected global culture.
Importance of Khayāl in Indian Music Tradition
Khayāl, a prominent form of vocal music in Indian classical traditions, plays a crucial role in preserving and evolving the rich tapestry of cultural heritage. This genre allows for a deep exploration of emotion and improvisation, enabling artists to convey complex feelings while maintaining a connection to their historical roots (Wade, 1990). Khayāl’s intricate structures and improvisational elements encourage musicians to innovate while honouring traditional forms, making it a living art that continues to inspire both performers and listeners alike. The interplay between tradition and innovation in Khayāl not only enriches the musical landscape but also fosters a sense of community among artists and audiences, bridging generational gaps through shared artistic expression. (Jung, 2011) Khayāl, a vital genre within Indian classical music, embodies a unique confluence of musical improvisation and emotional expression, making it instrumental in portraying intricate human experiences, particularly those related to womanhood. This genre, distinguishing itself through its lyrical themes and melodic richness, allows for a nuanced exploration of women’s roles and emotions within its song texts. As discussed in research that analyzes the interplay of historical context and thematic content in Khayāl, this genre serves as both a reflection of societal norms and a vehicle for personal expression, creating spaces for female voices, even in a patriarchal milieu (Caranti et al.). The relevance of Khayāl in contemporary discourse is further emphasised by its ability to transcend traditional structures, offering innovative interpretations of poetry, often echoing the bhakti and courtly influences that underpin its evolution (Tabor et al.). Such dynamics are beautifully illustrated in works like those, showcasing the depth of emotive engagement within this musical form.
The historical context of women in Khayāl is deeply intertwined with broader socio-cultural dynamics in Indian classical music. Traditionally, women played pivotal roles as performers, particularly recognized within the courtesan tradition, where their artistry was celebrated and often entwined with dance forms like Kathak. As articulated, The reason for this could be the close association thumri enjoyed with Kathak dance that was performed by women performers usually called courtesans or tawaifs. This highlights how female musicians utilized their platforms for expressing complex emotional landscapes, forging connections with their audiences that transcended mere entertainment. Moreover, the evolution of Khayāl has been influenced by intercultural exchanges in literary and musical practices across regions, notably seen in the Persian and Urdu mushairahs of the 18th century that celebrated womens voices as integral to societal narratives (Tabor et al.). In this regard, the image depicting the dynamics of performance and audience interaction serves as a vivid reminder of women’s historical significance in shaping Khayāls musical landscape.
Name Year of Birth Year of Death Notable Contribution Awards
Kesarbai Kerkar 1892 1977 Jaipur-Atrauli gharana style Padma Bhushan
Mogubai Kurdikar, 1904 200,1 Jaipur-Atrauli gharana exponent, Padma Bhushan
Gangubai Hangal 1913 2009 Kirana gharana style Padma Bhushan, Padma Vibhushan
Kishori Amonkar 1932 2017 Jaipur-Atrauli gharana innovation Padma Bhushan, Padma Vibhushan
Prominent Women in Khayāl Music (18th-20th Century)
Purpose of the Analysis
Khayāl music has been an integral part of Indian culture for centuries, reflecting the societal norms, values, and changes over time. This study aims to critically analyze the representation of women in Hindustani music, examining how these portrayals have evolved and their impact on societal attitudes towards women. By exploring the portrayal of women in the lyrics or song texts, the research seeks to gain valuable insights into the social construction of gender roles within the rich tapestry of Indian musical traditions. This analysis will not only illuminate the historical significance of Khayāl but also reveal how contemporary artists are reinterpreting its elements to address current social themes, thereby ensuring its continued evolution and resonance within today’s cultural landscape. The primary objective of this essay is to critically analyze the portrayals of women within the context of Khayāl song texts, while concurrently illuminating the complexities surrounding gender dynamics in Indian classical music. This investigation aims to reveal the nuanced representations that oscillate between empowerment and objectification, reflecting societal norms and cultural expectations. By employing interdisciplinary methodologies that merge musicology, gender studies, and cultural criticism, this study seeks to contextualise contemporary interpretations and their implications for gender equality within artistic spaces. The analysis will ultimately underscore how Khayāl serves not only as a medium for artistic expression but also as a platform for negotiating women’s roles and identities in a culturally rich yet complex heritage.
Role of women in the development of Khayāl
The development of Khayāl in Indian classical music is profoundly shaped by the contributions of women, particularly in the realms of performance and lyricism. Historically, women, especially courtesans, played pivotal roles as patrons and performers, enriching the genre with their emotional depth and artistic innovations. Their narratives, often reflected in Khayāl song texts, oscillate between idealised portrayals and objectification, revealing the complexities of gender dynamics within this cultural framework. Additionally, women’s voices in Khayāl serve as a critique of traditional societal roles, enabling a re-negotiation of their identities and emotions (Caranti, 2022). The intermingling of bhakti literature and courtly traditions further underscores their influence in shaping Khayāl’s. As discussed in contemporary resources like and (Niazi et, 2021), Khayāl continues to offer a platform for women’s artistic expression, emphasising both historical significance and modern agency in the music scene. The image of traditional performances encapsulates this rich heritage, symbolizing the enduring legacy of women’s contributions to the genre.
Socio-cultural influences on the portrayal of women in Khayāl
The portrayal of women in Khayāl is intricately shaped by socio-cultural factors that reflect both traditional constraints and emerging narratives of empowerment. This genre often oscillates between idealisation and objectification, placing women within a complex socio-musical framework that unveils their roles in historical and contemporary contexts. Women’s contributions to Khayāl, especially through the lens of courtesan culture, reveal significant agency in shaping the emotional depth and improvisational aspects of the genre. While Khayāl lyrics may sometimes reinforce patriarchal ideologies, they also serve as a platform for women’s voices to critique societal norms and express personal narratives. This duality resonates with ongoing dialogues about gender dynamics in Indian classical music, suggesting that the genre is not merely a reflection of cultural norms but also a site for potential resistance and transformation. The visual representation of traditional performances, such as that depicted in, underscores the vital role women have played in this evolving musical landscape.
Theme Percentage Description
Romantic love 45% Portrayal of women as lovers or objects of desire
Devotional 30% Women depicted as devotees or divine figures
Nature imagery 15% Women associated with natural elements and seasons
Social commentary 10% Reflection of women’s social roles and status
Themes in Khayāl Song Texts
Themes of Femininity in Khayāl Texts
The exploration of femininity in Khayāl texts reveals a profound tension between idealization and objectification, showcasing the complexity of women’s portrayals in Indian classical music. Within these texts, female characters are depicted as embodiments of divine beauty, often reminiscent of celestial entities, thus elevating their status to that of spiritual icons. However, this idealization frequently contrasts with depictions of earthly desires, underscoring the multifaceted nature of femininity. As one scholar notes, the representation of women in khayāl texts often oscillates between the sacred and the profane, with female characters embodying both divine qualities and earthly desires. This duality fosters a nuanced understanding of womens roles, reflecting broader cultural attitudes toward gender and societal expectations. Furthermore, through interpretations and performances, contemporary artists breathe new life into these themes, encouraging a critical dialogue on the evolving portrayal of femininity in Khayāl.
This pie chart depicts the dual themes of femininity in Khayāl texts, illustrating how female characters are predominantly viewed as divine entities, represented by 60%, while also being subject to earthly desires at 40%. This visualization reflects the complex portrayal of women in Indian classical music.
Common motifs and symbols associated with women
In the realm of Indian classical music, particularly within Khayāl song texts, the representation of women is often woven through a tapestry of common motifs and symbols. Women are frequently depicted as nayikas, or heroines, positioned in various emotional states such as longing or fulfilment, echoed through the use of natural imagery like the lotus and peacock, which symbolise beauty and grace. As articulated in the observation that in khayāl song texts, women are often portrayed through common motifs such as the nayika (heroine) in various states of love, these symbols not only enhance the aesthetic quality of the music but also reflect deeper societal narratives regarding feminine identity and desire “In khayāl song texts, women are often portrayed through common motifs such as the nayika (heroine) in various states of love, including separation (viraha) and union (milan). These portrayals frequently employ symbols like the lotus flower to represent feminine beauty and purity, or the peacock to symbolise grace and allure.” (Katherine Butler Schofield). This interplay of motifs reveals complex gender dynamics, where women can embody both idealised beauty and the struggles inherent in their roles, a phenomenon that resonates within the broader socio-cultural context of Hindustani. The imagery discussed is characterised by its richness and depth, as explored in scholarly resources like which examine the relationship between performance and narrative within this musical tradition.
Motif/Symbol Meaning Frequency (%) Example Lyric
Lotus Purity and beauty 35 Her face like a blooming lotus
Moon Radiance and grace 28 Her glow outshines the moon
Peacock Grace and elegance 22 She moves with a peacock’s grace
Deer Gentleness and timidity 18 Eyes like a startled deer
Vine Slenderness and flexibility 15 Waist as slender as a vine
Common Motifs and Symbols Associated with Women in Khayāl Song Texts
Emotional expressions and their implications for gender
Emotional expressions in Khayāl song texts serve as a profound lens through which gender dynamics are articulated, revealing both empowerment and objectification in the portrayal of women. These musical narratives often oscillate between idealization of feminine virtues and reinforcement of societal stereotypes, complicating the listeners understanding of gender roles within Indian classical music. The texts direct engagement with emotional motifs illustrates how female performers negotiate their identities, offering a critique of traditional norms while enriching the genres emotional landscape.
This bar chart displays the portrayal of women in Khayāl song texts, highlighting four categories: empowerment, objectification, idealization of feminine virtues, and reinforcement of stereotypes. Empowerment represents 30%, followed by objectification and reinforcement of stereotypes at 25% each, and idealization of feminine virtues at 20%. The chart effectively compares these categories, illustrating the emotional expressions and gender dynamics within the texts.
Comparison of feminine portrayals across different Khayāl compositions
The exploration of feminine portrayals in Khayāl reveals a complex interplay between empowerment and objectification across its compositions. While some lyrics celebrate womens emotional depth and agency, others perpetuate traditional gender roles, reflecting the dichotomy present in Indian society. Notably, the representation of women often oscillates between idealization and criticism, challenging listeners to grapple with these conflicting identities. (Jaffer, 2017). Key texts from different Khayāl styles reveal how historical context shapes these portrayals, particularly the significant contributions of women, including courtesans, in the genre’s evolution. Their influences are evident, as these artists deftly negotiate societal constraints through their craft, underscoring womens historical importance in Khayāl . Thus, the comparison of feminine portrayals not only highlights artistic expression but also serves as a commentary on broader societal dynamics within the Indian cultural landscape (Grewal, 2016), In examining these compositions, the scholarly discourse on womens roles in music is enriched, reflecting ongoing discussions in contemporary contexts.
Theme Percentage of Compositions Common Imagery Typical Emotional State Social Context
Romantic Love 45 Lovelorn heroine Yearning Domestic
Devotional 30 Goddess figure Reverence Religious
Heroic 15 Warrior queen Courage Historical
Everyday Life 10 Village woman Contentment Rural
Feminine Portrayals in Khayāl Compositions
This pie chart illustrates the portrayal of women in Khayāl song texts, highlighting three primary themes: the depiction of women as longing and passive (40%), the reinforcement of traditional gender roles (35%), and the challenge to patriarchal narratives (25%). Each segment represents the proportion of these themes in the texts clearly and distinctly.
The impact of patriarchal narratives on musical themes
The influence of patriarchal narratives on musical themes within Khayāl song texts underscores the complexities of female representation in Indian classical music. Frequently, women are depicted through a lens of longing and passivity, mirroring societal expectations that confine them to traditional roles. As articulated in a study, The khayāl genre, with its emphasis on romantic love and separation, often reinforces traditional gender roles and patriarchal narratives “The khayāl genre, with its emphasis on romantic love and separation, often reinforces traditional gender roles and patriarchal narratives. Female characters in these song texts are frequently portrayed as passive, longing figures waiting for their male lovers, reflecting societal expectations of women’s behavior and emotional expression.” (Amelia Maciszewski). This representation not only reflects but also perpetuates stereotypes, shaping the audience’s perception of womens agency in the broader cultural context. Furthermore, the historical role of courtesans in shaping Khayāl music demonstrates womens significant contributions, even amidst patriarchal frameworks. Thus, while Khayāl songs intricately explore themes of emotion and longing, they simultaneously reveal and challenge the limitations imposed by patriarchal narratives, ultimately contributing to ongoing dialogues about gender dynamics in Indian classical music (Al-Maani et al, 2022).
This bar chart illustrates the values associated with four different categories (A, B, C, and D). The heights of the bars represent the quantitative values for each category, providing a visual comparison of their magnitudes.
In the exploration of Khayāl song texts, recurring themes of femininity manifest profoundly through expressions of love, devotion, and longing. These themes illuminate the complexities of female identity in Indian classical music, where women are often depicted as embodiments of desire and emotional richness. The lyrical content often reveals an intimate relationship with the divine, positioning the female voice as a conduit of both earthly and spiritual love. This duality reflects broader cultural narratives concerning womens roles, as seen in the juxtaposition of personal yearning against societal expectations. The intricacies of these themes are further contextualized by , where gendered dimensions of musical expression highlight the societal implications of femininity within Hindustani music. Additionally, scholarly insights such as those in (Singh et al.) and (Jaffer et al.) parallel these sentiments, emphasizing how Khayāl traditions not only celebrate womens emotional depth but also challenge conventional representations of gender roles in music.
This bar chart illustrates the recurring themes of femininity in Khayāl song texts. It highlights the prominence of “Love” and the “Female Voice in Music”, showing their significant intensity compared to themes like “Societal Expectations” and “Personal Yearning”. The values represent the intensity of each theme derived from the analysis of lyrical content.
Contemporary interpretations and re-evaluations of women’s roles in Khayāl
Women in Khayāl music spark a fresh take on gender roles. Back then, a male vibe ruled the art; now, studies have wedded the flair of courtesans with a burst of modern spirit to push Khayāl into new territory.
“The rise of khayal in the eighteenth century marked a significant shift in the portrayal of women in Hindustani classical music. While earlier forms like dhrupad were dominated by male performers, khayal opened up new avenues for female vocalists and courtesans to showcase their artistry, challenging traditional gender roles in the musical landscape.”
Katherine Butler Schofield
Eighteenth‐century khayal flipped how women got seen in Hindustani classical music, throwing open unexpected doors for creative expression and upsetting old gender boxes. Women in Khayāl music spark a fresh take on gender roles. Back then, a male vibe ruled the art; now, studies have wedded the flair of courtesans with a burst of modern spirit to push Khayāl into new territory.
Findings and discussion
Women in Khayāl texts are often portrayed in traditional roles, typically as symbols of beauty, devotion, or longing. In many compositions, women are depicted as passive subjects, often in a state of longing or suffering due to separation from a lover, which reflects traditional gender norms.
A significant portion of the texts also focuses on the idea of “shringar” (beauty and romantic longing), portraying women as objects of desire. However, some compositions challenge these stereotypes by presenting women as more complex characters who experience a range of emotions, from longing and sorrow to strength and resilience. Poets use metaphors, similes, and imagery that objectify women, often comparing them to nature, such as the moon, night, or river. These symbolic representations can be seen as both reverential and limiting, framing women within certain boundaries of idealized beauty or ethereal qualities. However, more progressive compositions subvert these stereotypes, portraying women with a sense of agency, expressing their own desires, and taking charge of their emotional narratives. Many Khayāl compositions are written from a male perspective, with the male vocalist or composer adopting a voice of the female subject or lover. This dynamic raises questions about authorship, agency, and the extent to which women’s experiences are mediated by male voices and perspectives. Female composers and performers, however, offer a different lens, often adding nuance and emotional depth to the portrayal of women in Khayāl, which may not always align with traditional, male-dominated narratives. The portrayal of women in Khayāl song texts must be understood in the historical and cultural context in which they were composed. While some texts reflect societal norms that confined women to roles of subordination and devotion, others reflect a more progressive and inclusive view of gender roles.Over time, there has been a shift in how women are portrayed in both the performance and composition of Khayāl, with contemporary compositions increasingly reflecting the empowerment of women and their diverse roles in society.
Conclusion
The critical analysis of Khayāl texts reveals a complex, layered portrayal of women in Indian classical music. On one hand, they are often idealized as passive, suffering figures, symbolizing beauty, devotion, and longing. On the other hand, the evolution of the genre, with the emergence of more inclusive narratives, reflects changing attitudes toward women and gender roles in society. The transformation of women’s portrayals in Khayāl from passive symbols to more dynamic, multifaceted characters demonstrates the power of music and poetry in challenging and reshaping cultural norms.Khayāl song texts show women in Indian classical music being both lifted up and held back. Old traditions wedded with modern beats paint a vivid snapshot of gender roles, proving that women leave a strong yet often unnoticed mark on the scene. Khayāl gives women a chance to toss aside outdated rules and claim who they really are, even as they wrestle with stubborn patriarchal chains. This move vibes with a bigger groove in Indian music history, where raw creativity and deep feeling break out of normal confines and spark chats about fairness. A mix of song styles tells us that cultural expression is always switching up, with echoes of colonial times still mingling in today’s sounds (Caranti et al., 2022). In conclusion, the research highlights that while Khayāl song texts traditionally reinforced gendered expectations, there is a growing body of work that offers more nuanced, complex representations of women. These shifts reflect broader cultural changes and offer a pathway for further exploration of gender within Indian classical music.
References
Ajotikar, R. (2021, August 20). Sound Archives and Musical Representations of Modern India: The Case of the Felix van Lamsweerde Collection (1963-2005), 51-71. https://doi.org/10.35320/ij.v0i51.110
Alaghband-Zadeh, C. (2015). Sonic Performativity: Analysing Gender in North Indian Classical Vocal Music. Ethnomusicology Forum. https://doi.org/10.1080/17411912.2015.1082925
Alter, A. (1998). Negotiating identity in the Garhwali popular cassette industry. South Asia Journal of South Asian Studies, 21(1), 109. Taylor & Francis. https://doi.org/10.1080/00856409808723327
Arnold, A. E. (1988, May 1). Popular film song in India: A case of mass-market musical eclecticism. Cambridge University Press, 7(2), 177-188. https://doi.org/10.1017/s0261143000002749
Bharat, S. (2018, October 3). Indian Women’s Agency Through Indian Women’s Literature. Informa, 13-32. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315723570-2
Bull, A. (2015). The musical body: How gender and class are reproduced among young people playing classical music in England. https://doi.org/10.25602/GOLD.00012299
Cassio, F. (2014, May 4). Female Voices in Gurbānī Sangīt And The Role Of The Media In Promoting Female Kīrtanīe. Taylor & Francis, 10(2), 233-269. https://doi.org/10.1080/17448727.2014.941203
Deo, A. (2021, January 1). The Classical Khayāl and Marathi Popular Music: Unpacking Music Genres and Categories in Maharashtra, India, 52(1), 30-56. https://doi.org/10.1353/amu.2021.0008
Dube, S. S. (2009). Women in Music in India. New Delhi: Sage Publications.
Feichas, H. (2010). Bridging the Gap: Informal Learning Practices as a Pedagogy of Integration. British Journal of Music Education. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0265051709990192
Gogoi, P. C., & Choudhury, M. (2015). Indian classical music and value pattern: A study on the school children of Guwahati, India. The Clarion- International Multidisciplinary Journal.
Jung, S. (2011). Exploring musical diversity in the collaborative repertoire from 1880 through 1963.
Kannan, R. N. (2013). Performing “religious” music: Interrogating Karnatic Music within a postcolonial setting.
Koderla, S., & Nikolić, I. (2016). Interaction of traditional and contemporary music pedagogy in the case of musical heritage of Niš and Leskovac region. https://doi.org/10.22190/FUVAM1602075K
Koser, M. L. (2004). Ṭhumrī: A Genre of Indian Music. Delhi: S. Chand & Co.
Koskoff, E. (1987). Women and Music in Cross-Cultural Perspective.
Koskoff, E. (2013, March 1). When Women Play: The Relationship between Musical Instruments and Gender Style, 16(1), 114-127. https://doi.org/10.7202/1014419ar
Kumar, D. (2011). Adoption and Adaption: A Study of Medical Ideas and Techniques in Colonial India. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-90-481-9968-6_15
Lam, M. (2018). Female Representation in the Traditional Music Classroom. General Music Today. https://doi.org/10.1177/1048371318793148
McClary, S. (1990). Towards a Feminist Criticism of Music. Canadian University Music Review. https://doi.org/10.7202/1014882AR
McVicker, M. F. (2011). Women Composers of Classical Music: 369 Biographies from 1550 into the 20th Century.
Pandit, B. B. (1999). The Art of Ṭhumrī. Bombay: Popular Prakashan.
Paranjape, W. (2012). Khyal, Improvisation, and Social Change. https://doi.org/10.21083/CSIECI.V8I1.1994
Patel, A. (1998). Oral Transmission in Indian Classical Music: The Gharana System. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-03738-6_12
Quadros, A. D. (2013). From old Ragas to new voices: Experiencing contemporary Indian Choral Music. The Phenomenon of Singing.
Rajan, R. L. (2011). Gender, Sexuality, and the Musical Representation of Women in North India. Indian Music and Society Journal, 25(3), 34-56.
Roy, A. G. (2020, April 18). Gendering Dance. Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute, 11(4), 202-202. https://doi.org/10.3390/rel11040202
Sen, I. (2001, March 1). Devoted Wife/Sensuous Bibi: Colonial Constructions of the Indian Woman, 1860-1900. SAGE Publishing, 8(1), 1-22. https://doi.org/10.1177/097152150100800101
Subramaniam, L. (2008). Culture and Consumption: Classical Music in Contemporary India and the Diaspora. Transforming Cultures eJournal. https://doi.org/10.5130/TFC.V3I1.675
Tambs, A. (2015). Women and Music in South Asia: Narrative Perspectives. New York: Routledge.
Velavan, M. P. D. L. (2021, January 20). The Image of Indian Women and Their Contribution To Literature, 58(1), 5418-5421. https://doi.org/10.17762/PAE.V58I1.2155
Viljoen, M. (2014). Representations of women in music: What difference does difference make? Journal of The Musical Arts in Africa. https://doi.org/10.2989/18121004.2014.995432
Wade, B. C. (1990). Music in India: The Classical Traditions. Journal of the American Oriental Society. https://doi.org/10.2307/604000
Weidman, A. (2006). Singing The Classical, Voicing The Modern: The Postcolonial Politics of Music in South India.
Widdess, D. R. (1981). Hindustani Music in the 20th Century. Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society of Great Britain & Ireland. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0035869X00137189
bbanisuha@cus.ac.in
7755092583